Retirement in the Empire State: More Than Just a Nice View

02/17/2025

 

Is New York a tax-friendly state for retirees? If you listen to the headlines, you might think the answer is a resounding "no." We’ve all seen the charts ranking the Empire State at the top of the "most taxed" lists.

But in fact New York’s tax code is a fortress of protections for seniors. Between total exemptions on Social Security, massive exclusions for pension income, and targeted property tax breaks, many seniors find that their effective state tax rate drops significantly the moment they hit retirement age.

Let’s break down the strategic advantages that New York offers to those entering their golden years.

The Big Three of Income Protection

New York doesn't just pay lip service to helping seniors; it offers a literal shield against state income tax on three primary fronts.

 

1. The Social Security Safe Haven

Unlike the federal government—which can tax up to 85% of your Social Security benefits—New York State is a "zero-tax" zone for Social Security. Every dollar you receive from the Social Security Administration is subtracted from your federal adjusted gross income when calculating your New York taxes. Whether you’re receiving $20,000 or $50,000 in benefits, the state’s share is $0.

2. The $20,000 Pension and Annuity Exclusion

If you are 59½ or older, New York allows you to exclude up to $20,000 of qualified retirement income from your state taxes every year.

What counts as "qualified"? The list is broad:

  • Private pensions and annuities
  • Distributions from IRAs (Traditional and Roth)
  • 401(k) and 403(b) distributions
  • Keogh plan distributions

For a married couple where both spouses are over 59½ and have their own retirement accounts, this exclusion jumps to $40,000. That is a significant chunk of income that New York simply ignores.

A Note on Legacy Planning: A frequently overlooked advantage is that these exclusions can extend beyond your own retirement. If you receive an inherited pension or IRA, you may still be eligible for this $20,000 exclusion. Crucially, in the case of an inherited benefit, the exclusion can apply regardless of your age, provided the original owner would have been at least 59½. It’s a powerful tool for multi-generational wealth preservation.

3. The "Government Unlimited" Rule

If you were a career public servant (teachers, police & fire, civil servants, military, federal government) your pension is generally 100% exempt from New York State and local taxes. There is no $20,000 cap here. Whether your state pension is $30,000 or $130,000, it is usually untouchable by the NYS Department of Taxation and Finance.

Property Tax Relief

For most New Yorkers, the biggest tax hurdle isn't income; it’s the school and property tax bill. For seniors, the state provides two major relief valves: Enhanced STAR and the Senior Citizens Exemption.

  • Enhanced STAR: While most homeowners get the more limited basic STAR credit, seniors 65 and older with qualifying incomes (for 2026, the limit is $110,750 or less) receive a significantly higher exemption. This can slash thousands off a school tax bill.
  • The Senior Citizens Exemption: This is a local option that can reduce the assessed value of your home by up to 50% to 65%, depending on your municipality. New legislation in 2026 has expanded these limits, allowing local governments to be even more generous to their older residents on fixed incomes.

Long-Term Care

One of the most powerful moves in a tax planner’s playbook is the Long-Term Care (LTC) insurance credit. Currently, New York offers a credit equal to 20% of your premiums, capped at $1,500 per year for those with an adjusted gross income under $250,000.

2026 Watch-List: There is active legislation (Senate Bill S4698) currently moving through the state legislature that proposes eliminating the $1,500 cap and the $250k income limit entirely. If passed, this would allow high-income earners to deduct 20% of their total premiums without a ceiling—a massive shift for estate planning. With strong bipartisan support, this proposal warrants close monitoring.

Strategy Over Mechanics

We don't focus on the forms; we focus on the benefit. Proper tax planning for a senior in New York isn't just about filing; it’s about timing.

  • Should you take more from your IRA this year to max out the $20,000 exclusion?
  • Should you accelerate a pension payout if the LTC credit cap is eliminated?
  • Is your residency correctly established to ensure you aren't paying NYC local taxes on that exempt pension?

The IRS and the New York Department of Taxation and Finance have very clear rules, but they don't send you a "thank you" note if you overpay.

 

Sign up today for a FREE discovery call.

 

Greg Tobias, Enrolled Agent

Admitted to practice before the Internal Revenue Service

 

Sources:

  • NYS Tax Law Section 612(c)(3) and (3-a)
  • NYS Publication 36: General Information for Senior Citizens and Retired Persons
  • NYS Real Property Tax Law Section 425 (STAR) and 467 (Senior Citizens Exemption)
  • Internal Revenue Code Section 86 (Social Security benefits)
  • NYS Senate Bill S4698 (Long-Term Care Credit amendments)

Read On